[TMG Exclusive] Speaking truth to Parliament
MEMBERS of Parliament are busy people, we all know that. Most of them have full-time jobs. But still they have to find the time to look after you – their constituents. From dealing with parking fines, to deciding how much to spend and on what, no issue is too big or small for the people you voted to represent you in the G.
The big issues are debated in Parliament and – not including the upcoming sitting on August 17 – there have been a total of 115 sessions since the last election in 2011.
Now that GE2015 is on the horizon, we had one question: How often is your MP showing up in Parliament, and how hard is he (or she) working to speak up for you?
The results will surprise you. MPs whom you might expect to be quite vocal turned out not so; and only two MPs attended all 115 sittings. Who? Read on.
The reason we looked into this was simple: Over the past few years, the attention on MPs has focused on their duties and responsibilities as town councillors. This is an important aspect of their work – to ensure that they are able to run the housing estates under their charge.
But what underpins this work is a more fundamental duty: to speak up for the people, scrutinise new legislation, and check against G excesses.
This was a point that PM himself made right after the 2011 General Election, in a seven-page letter addressed to his party’s MPs. In the letter, titled Rules of Prudence, PM Lee laid down how he thought an MP should behave.
Topping the list with regards to Parliament? Showing up.
“MPs are expected to attend all sittings of Parliament,” he wrote. “If you have to be absent from any sitting, seek the prior permission of the Government Whip. Please inform the Whip if you have to leave the Parliament premises while a sitting is on.”
Read the full letter here.
To find out how many times each MP showed up in Parliament, we looked at every single Voters and Proceedings document filed by the 12th Parliament. As there have been 115 sittings, there were 115 reports. We combed through all of them, counted who showed up how many times, and put that into a table.
Party Member of Parliament GRC/SMC Total Attendance from 2011-2015
PAP Lee Bee Wah Nee Soon 111
PAP Zainal Bin Sapari Pasir-Ris Punggol 110
PAP Gan Thiam Poh Pasir-Ris Punggol 108
PAP Christopher De Souza Holland-Bukit Timah 110
PAP David Ong Kim Huat Jurong 107
PAP Zaqy Mohamad Chua Chu Kang 100
PAP Ang Wei Neng Jurong 114
PAP Baey Yam Keng Tampines 112
PAP Tin Pei Ling Marine Parade 106
PAP Alex Yam Ziming Chua Chu Kang 110
PAP Tay Teck Guan Patrick Nee Soon 108
PAP Intan Azura Minte Mokhtar Ang Mo Kio 108
PAP Fatimah Lateef Marine Parade 94
PAP Foo Mee Har West Coast 108
PAP Lim Biow Chuan Mountbatten 112
PAP Hri Kumar Nair Bishan-Toa Payoh 105
PAP Irene Ng Phek Hoong Tampines 93
PAP Yeo Guat Kwang Ang Mo Kio 104
PAP Ang Hin Kee Ang Mo Kio 104
PAP Liang Eng Hwa Holland-Bukit Timah 112
PAP Janil Puthucheary Pasir-Ris Punggol 113
PAP Lim Wee Kiak Nee Soon 112
PAP Ellen Lee Geck Hoon Sembawang 110
PAP Vikram Nair Sembawang 107
PAP Sitoh Yih Pin Potong Pasir 111
PAP Zainudin Nordin Bishan-Toa Payoh 108
PAP Chia Shi-Lu Tanjong Pagar 100
PAP Penny Low Pasir-Ris Punggol 105
PAP Lily Neo Tanjong Pagar 104
PAP Seng Han Thong Ang Mo Kio 110
PAP Arthur Fong West Coast 102
PAP Jessica Tan Soon Neo East Coast 97
PAP Ong Teng Koon Sembawang 100
PAP Edwin Tong Chui Fai Moulmein-Kallang 106
PAP Cedric Foo Chee Keng Pioneer 95
PAP Inderjit Singh Ang Mo Kio 99
PAP Alvin Yeo Chua Chu Kang 95
PAP Wong Kan Seng Bishan-Toa Payoh 106
PAP Mah Bow Tan Tampines 82
PAP Raymond Lim East Coast 82
WP Low Thia Khiang Aljunied 115
WP Sylvia Lim Aljunied 113
WP Chen Show Mao Aljunied 108
WP Muhamad Faisal Bin Abdul Manap Aljunied 114
WP Pritam Singh Aljunied 114
WP Png Eng Huat Hougang 89
WP Lee Li Lian Punggol East 73
WP Yaw Shin Leong Hougang 13
NCMP (SPP) Lina Chiam NCMP (Potong Pasir) 113
NCMP(WP) Gerald Giam Yean Song NCMP (East Coast) 115
NCMP (WP) Yee Jenn Jong NCMP (Joo Chiat) 110
We focused on backbenchers, because they are the ones who often have the most direct contact with the people on the ground and thus most likely to be in tune with how policy is perceived, or whether policy-makers have got it right in responding to public need.
What we found, after several days of pulling together these public records, quite frankly surprised us. For example, you’ll see that not one single PAP MP attended all 115 sittings. The most number of times was 114, with Mr Ang Wei Neng (Jurong) in top spot. He was followed by Mr Janil Puthucheary (Pasir Ris-Punggol) with 113, and Mr Baey Yam Keng (Tampines), Mr Lim Biow Chuan (Mountbatten), Mr Liang Eng Hwa (Holland-Bukit Timah), and Mr Lim Wee Kiak (Nee Soon), all of whom attended 112 sessions.
On the Workers’ Party side, there were two people who attended all 115 sittings: Mr Low Thia Khiang (Aljunied) and Mr Gerald Giam, a Non-Constituency MP (NCMP). Mr Low’s fellow Aljunied members Muhamad Faisal and Pritam Singh came a close second, attending 114 sessions, and Ms Sylvia Lim, also in Aljunied GRC, attended 113.
NCMP Lina Chiam also had one of the highest attendance rates at 113 sittings.
Who attended the least number of sessions?
Mr Yaw Shin Leong from the Workers’ Party at only 13 sittings, but he was in Parliament for only two years from 2011 to 2012. Comparing MPs who were in Parliament throughout the 2011-2015 period, it was a tie between Mr Mah Bow Tan (Tampines) and Mr Raymond Lim (East Coast) – though, at 82 sittings both former ministers’ attendance rate is still at about 70 per cent.
Mark my words
We then turned our attention to how many times each backbencher spoke or raised an issue in Parliament. We combed through the Parliament Reports, also known as the Hansard records, hoping to find out which backbenchers in the 12th Parliament were the most vocal in questioning the G and raising issues to be discussed and debated.
As a baseline for comparison, we counted the number of sittings when individual backbencher MPs spoke up, rather than how many instances of speaking altogether. Here’s what we found:
Party Member of Parliament GRC/SMC Total number of times spoken in Parliament from 2011-2015
PAP Lee Bee Wah Nee Soon 87
PAP Zainal Bin Sapari Pasir-Ris Punggol 79
PAP Gan Thiam Poh Pasir-Ris Punggol 77
PAP Christopher De Souza Holland-Bukit Timah 71
PAP David Ong Kim Huat Jurong 71
PAP Zaqy Mohamad Chua Chu Kang 71
PAP Ang Wei Neng Jurong 70
PAP Baey Yam Keng Tampines 68
PAP Tin Pei Ling Marine Parade 66
PAP Alex Yam Ziming Chua Chu Kang 65
PAP Tay Teck Guan Patrick Nee Soon 63
PAP Intan Azura Minte Mokhtar Ang Mo Kio 62
PAP Fatimah Lateef Marine Parade 61
PAP Foo Mee Har West Coast 60
PAP Lim Biow Chuan Mountbatten 60
PAP Hri Kumar Nair Bishan-Toa Payoh 58
PAP Irene Ng Phek Hoong Tampines 58
PAP Yeo Guat Kwang Ang Mo Kio 57
PAP Ang Hin Kee Ang Mo Kio 55
PAP Liang Eng Hwa Holland-Bukit Timah 53
PAP Janil Puthucheary Pasir-Ris Punggol 49
PAP Lim Wee Kiak Nee Soon 49
PAP Ellen lee Geck Hoon Sembawang 48
PAP Vikram Nair Sembawang 45
PAP Sitoh Yih Pin Potong Pasir 39
PAP Zainudin Nordin Bishan-Toa Payoh 39
PAP Chia Shi-Lu Tanjong Pagar 38
PAP Penny Low Pasir-Ris Punggol 36
PAP Lily Neo Tanjong Pagar 36
PAP Seng Han Thong Ang Mo Kio 33
PAP Arthur Fong West Coast 32
PAP Jessica Tan Soon Neo East Coast 30
PAP Ong Teng Koon Sembawang 25
PAP Edwin Tong Chui Fai Moulmein-Kallang 24
PAP Cedric Foo Chee Keng Pioneer 22
PAP Inderjit Singh Ang Mo Kio 20
PAP Alvin Yeo Chua Chu Kang 16
PAP Wong Kan Seng Bishan-Toa Payoh 2
PAP Mah Bow Tan Tampines 1
PAP Raymond Lim East Coast 0
WP Low Thia Khiang Aljunied 54
WP Sylvia Lim Aljunied 70
WP Chen Show Mao Aljunied 45
WP Muhamad Faisal Bin Abdul Manap Aljunied 70
WP Pritam Singh Aljunied 77
WP Png Eng Huat Hougang 59
WP Lee Li Lian Punggol East 46
WP Yaw Shin Leong Hougang 7
NCMP (SPP) Lina Chiam NCMP (Potong Pasir) 83
NCMP (WP) Gerald Giam Yean Song NCMP (East Coast) 80
NCMP (WP) Yee Jenn Jong NCMP (Joo Chiat) 87
The most outspoken MP was Dr Lee Bee Wah (Nee Soon), who spoke up in 87 sittings. The head of the Government Parliamentary Committee (GPC) on National Development and Environment dwelt mainly on her area of focus, particularly on housing issues such as the waiting time to apply and obtain for HDB rental flats and the cost of buying HDB flats.
For the rest of the time, she spoke on topics ranging from hospitalisation care, benefits for foreign workers to promoting sporting activities in schools. She once suggested that the Transport Ministry stop ERP charges during evenings and Saturdays so that family members could visit each other.
In second place was Mr Zainal Sapari (Pasir Ris-Punggol), who spoke in 79 sessions of Parliament. The Labour MP made many suggestions, including extending the usage of the Post-Secondary Education (PSE) Accounts to include degree programmes in private institutions, revising the target for low-wage workers’ salaries to increase in real terms by 50 per cent, and allowing foreign workers in the service sectors to be housed at approved purpose-built dormitories like their counterparts in the construction and marine sector.
Coming in third was Mr Gan Thiam Poh, also an MP for Pasir Ris-Punggol. In the 77 sessions of Parliament in which he spoke up, Mr Gan proposed ideas such as providing free MediShield coverage to the lowest 20 percentile of citizens with a per capita income of $750 and under. He also supported the introduction of a new family car category for COE, and the increase in the Special CPF Housing Grant to lower income families who have more than three children to buy their own flats of three rooms or less.
We were surprised that MP Inderjit Singh (Ang Mo Kio), known for his frank eloquence, spoke only in 20 of the 115 Parliament sittings. Perhaps, this was proof that it matters more what you say, than how often or loud you say it.
At the bottom of the list were the former ministers. Mr Raymond Lim (East Coast) spoke up zero times. Not once in all the 115 Parliament sessions held since 2011. Then there’s Mr Mah Bow Tan, who spoke only once, and Mr Wong Kan Seng (Bishan-Toa Payoh) who spoke twice.
This also surprised us, not least because we expected Mr Lim, Mr Mah and Mr Wong, all of whom are long-serving MPs, to have quite a lot to contribute in Parliament.
Mr Wong himself served as Home Affairs Minister and was Deputy Prime Minister from 2005 to 2011, but since he retired from the Cabinet in 2011, he has only spoken twice – once in 2013 to defend the G’s Population White Paper, and the second in 2015 in a tribute to the former PM Lee Kuan Yew.
We turned to PAP to see if they could help us understand what we uncovered. Was there a reason for the ministers’ silence – was it party policy, or a matter of personal preference, for example?
Also: Does the PAP keep track of these records? Were PM Lee’s Rules of Prudence binding in any way?
We sent our questions to the PAP on Monday and requested that it reply us by Tuesday. Yesterday evening, it said it regretfully could not respond to our queries given the short deadline we gave them.
Within the Workers’ Party, the most vocal MP was Mr Pritam Singh (Aljunied), who spoke during 77 sittings. The MP who spoke in the least sittings – not including MPs Lee Li Lian, Png Eng Huat and Yaw Shin Leong, all of whom were voted in as MPs for only part of the four-year term (2011-2015) – was Mr Chen Show Mao (Aljunied), who spoke 45 times.
NCMPs spoke up the most number of times among the Opposition, with WP’s Yee Jenn Jong leading the group at 87 times, followed by Ms Lina Chiam (83 times) and Mr Gerald Giam (80 times).
Not counting the 39 office-holders, there are 40 PAP backbenchers in Parliament, including 17 first-term MPs. Out of these,11 are heads of Government Parliamentary Committees (GPC), which are set up to focus on specific areas such as education, transport, and health.
GPC Chairman Committee Portfolio Number of times spoken on issues not related to GPC Number of times spoken on GPC Total number of times spoken
Sitoh Yih Pin Defence and Foreign Affairs 51 20 71
Lim Biow Chuan Education 141 35 176
Liang Eng Hwa Finance, Trade & Industry 76 26 102
Chia Shi-Lu Health 22 35 57
Hri Kumar Nair Home Affairs, Law 43 71 112
Zaqy Mohamad Communications and Information 146 37 183
Zainudin Nordin Manpower 50 15 65
Lee Bee Wah National Development and Environment 141 142 283
Cedric Foo Transport 11 26 37
Baey Yam Keng Culture, Community and Youth/Deputy chair in Communication and Information 48 80 128
The most active backbencher was still Dr Lee Bee Wah, who as chairwoman of the National Development and Environment GPC spoke a total of 238 times, about half of which were on issues related to her GPC.
Coming in second among the GPC leaders was Mr Zaqy Mohamad (Chua Chu Kang), who heads the Communications and Information GPC. Eight times out of 10, he discussed diverse issues outside of the scope of his GPC. Of the 71 sessions in Parliament that he spoke in, he broached many issues for the Malay community like their health concerns, and how Muis can better enable the Muslim community in Singapore to manage the challenges in the Islamic world.
During one of those sessions in Parliament, he had asked the Foreign Minister how he was going to communicate the G’s position to Muslims and non-Muslims regarding the Gaza Conflict so as to manage the potential divisiveness of the issue.
In third place was Mr Lim Biow Chuan (Mountbatten), head of the Education GPC, who contributed to the forum mostly on non-education issues during the 176 occasions that he spoke.
Rather surprisingly, another GPC chairman was placed close to the end of the “speaking” list. Mr Cedric Foo (Pioneer), chairman of the Transport GPC, spoke up at only 22 sittings, even though public transport has been a primary concern of Singaporeans in recent time. Mr Foo used to be a Minister of State for the Ministry of Defence in 2002 after leaving Singapore Airlines, He took on the additional portfolio for the Ministry of National Development in 2004, until May 2005 when he returned to the private sector by joining NOL.
During the 22 sittings, he spoke 37 times, mostly regarding transport issues.
Rules or guidelines?
The 2011 General Election was considered by many to be a “watershed election”, with the PAP garnering 60.1 per cent of the general vote and losing its first GRC to the Workers’ Party.
PM Lee’s Rules of Prudence described the task that laid ahead for his party’s MPs: “You have to listen hard to voter concerns, help them to tackle pressing needs, reflect their worries and aspirations to the Government and persuade them to support policies which are in their own long term benefit.”
What conclusions are we to draw from these records, if any? If the Prime Minister expects MPs to attend all Parliament sittings, is a 70 per cent attendance rate good enough? Are your MPs speaking up enough to reflect your concerns in a substantive way?
We can only guess at what the PM might say. What say you?
Reporting by Joshua Lim, Nicholas Khaw, Jesselyn Lee, and Cindy Co.
[Editor’s note: The total number of Parliament sittings since GE2011 is 115, as reported in our story. The session on 25 February 2013 was missing from the Voters and Proceedings page on Parliament’s website but appeared in the Hansard records.]
Featured photo by Shawn Danker.
If you like this article, like The Middle Ground‘s Facebook Page as well!
For breaking news, you can talk to us via email.